On Mnet’s ‘Idol Chart Show’, singers were ranked by their MR removed clips and Taeyeon grabbed 3rd place.
Top 5 for (MR removed singers):
#1 DBSK (HoMin)
#4 2am Changmin
#5 Park Bom
For those who don’t know what MR removed clips are, they’re clips that minimize any MR (music recorded) in the song and maximize the vocals of the singer. MR-removed clips/videos can help prove singers’ power vocals.
Personally, I think she could’ve ranked higher, but I’m not going complain since she’s in Top 3. Congrats to Taeng! To celebrate, here are a couple of MR removed clips I’ve found. I love her ‘I Love You’ the most.
(SNSD MR removed clips)
Sources: as tagged + Sookyeong + duduaria@Soompi + respective uploaders on YouTube
IU have high notes but Taeyeon have much strong and beautiful voice… Even her busy with snsd, her solo OST and duet still hit. Taeyeon much better want put emotion at song her sing. That make her always make the her solo hit. Her have aura at her voice and personality.
Dang, instead of the MR removed, it should be MC REMOVED, those darn hosts in the video were so noisy, just let us listen to her awesome voice. I think Top 3 is as good as she can rank, it’s hard to argue against those two above her… TVXQ is insanely good live, and IU is IU.
Taeyeon vocal skills is so much better, iu can hit high note very nicely. But taeyeon voice is more beautiful.
i still blur about the mr thingy…..
is it that the music is reduce and maximize the singer’s voice?
proud of you taeyeon….
although she didnt rank a very very high place, but for me it is very very super duper good..
because we cant deny other artist’s ability and power……
SNSD, fighting! ^^
the MR removed Star Star Star video isn’t MR removed for taeyeon lol. i remember that time she had some problems with her throat so they used their recording instead.
I honestly think 3rd place does Taeng justice. IU and HoMin are more skilled in the various techniques of singing, whilst Taeng’s voice is still very strong and beautiful. Congrats, Tae!
I just noticed that in Dear Mom, the audio is MR removed from the ACTUAL song, NOT the live version. Although the chorus tells me otherwise. Love the MR removed versions, they sound so damn good.
woah seriously, as a bit of a singer myself, i totally feel her vocals are just so awesome…the feelings conveyed in this song has been totally expressed so fully that i actually had tears in my eyes…. Just so amazing….
though she came third Taeyeon will always be number one in our heart ❤
Taeyeon is JJANG to the MAX <33333 !!! She's actually one of the MAIN reasons that I've become a fervent SONE in so short a time ;). Her vocal abilities are simply AMAZING (in my "book") 😀 ! To me, she'll Always be Number One 🙂 😀 !!!
lol I think it should be BMR removed not MR removed, BMR being Background music recorded, because singing IS music! lol
Anyway, I really really believe that our Taeyeon should have been ranked ABOVE IU,
I don’t know anything about DBSK’s HoMin, so I can’t comment there, but I’ve heard IU’s songs, and while she has a large vocal range, and can hit those really high notes, she really, IMO, lacks any power and strength in her singing, it sounds too superficial
but Taengoo, wow, her singing is just out of this world beautiful, the perfect vocals that she has simply puts me in heaven! Her strength and power in singing, vocal range, the depth, everything just fits so well
TAEYEON ALWAYS #1!!!!!!!!!!
But I am still very proud she ranked 3rd on this ranking! huge accomplishment as always for soshi!
TAEYEON AND SOSHI FIGHTING!!!!!!!!!!!
IU cannot sing. She uses falsetto and has too much air in her voice. Taeyeon projects and solid on her singing. People that voted for IU are just simply voting for stuff other than her vocal ability. Maybe Korea needs to learn how to train singers properly.
“Personally, I think she could’ve ranked higher, but I’m not going complain since she’s in Top 3. Congrats to Taeng!”
I couldn’t agree more!
To be honest, I’m not a fan of IU’s voice because it’s too mushy, I should say.
TaeYeon’s voice on the other hand is strong and powerful.
I love that. ^^ <333
Wow, the MR removed for 'Dear. Mom' left me speechless.
But then I found out it was from the recordings, but still amazing. ♥
TaeYeon's voice is just WOW! ♥
Those MCs were annoying the heck out of me! <_<
They were talking way too much!
I was just like, "Can you shut up so I can hear my baby's amazing voice instead of your lousy ones? -_-"
not to be biased but all of snsd member’s voice is nice without music. they are all great.!!!
and why those mc had to comment on everything?? seriously annoying